In the event of failure to meet the requirements for applying the exemption for reinvestment in a main residence, the Supreme Court has ruled that the Administration cannot initiate proceedings until the deadline for filing the supplementary return has expired that regularises the application of the exemption
The exemption for reinvestment in a main residence regulated in article 38.1 of Personal Income Tax Law 35/2006 and article 41 of its Regulations, establishes, among other requirements, that in order to apply it the taxpayer must reinvest the amount obtained within a period of no more than 2 years from the date of transfer of the main residence.
In the event of non-compliance, it is the taxpayer who must regularise their situation by filing a supplementary return.
In the case that is the subject of the Judgment, the claimant considers that the four-year limitation period starts to run when the 2-year period for reinvestment ends. However, the Administration understood that the limitation period starts to run when the deadline for filing the supplementary return for the year in which the non-compliance occurs ends.
Finally, the Supreme Court has ruled in its Judgment number 679/2020, of 26 February 2020, in the same way as the Administration and the High Court of Justice of Madrid in the appealed judgment, concluding that "the administration cannot initiate any tax regularisation action aimed at assessing the tax and, therefore, the limitation period does not begin until both circumstances occur provided for by the legal and regulatory provisions on the reinvestment exemption: (i) firstly, that the two-year period ends from the transfer of the main residence, which in this case occurred on 5 May 2007 since the sale took place on 5 May 2005 and, in addition, (ii) that the deadline for filing the supplementary return has passed regularising the capital gain that was exempt due to the reinvestment commitment, a return that could be filed until 30 June 2008, when the filing period ended for the year in which the non-compliance occurred."